Similarities:

Question

Communism-Communism aimed to eliminate worker exploitation.
Socialism-Socialism originated from the desire to limit worker exploitation.
Communism-Communism had the ideology of eliminating the influence of economic classes in society.
Socialism-As well as in communism, socialism aimed to lower the influence of economic classes in society.
Communism-In communism it is assumed that all goods and services will be produced by the government controlled institutions or collective organizatiions instead rather than by privately owned businesses.
Socialism- Additionally, socialism also assumes that all goods and services will be produced by government institutions or collective organizations. Socialism emphasizes public ownership and control over key industries and services to ensure equal distribution and access.
Differences:
Communism-In communism there is no such thing as private property.
Socialism-Under socialism, individuals can still own property.
Communism-In communism, the people are compensated based on what the government think are their needs by providing most or all food,clothing, housing, and other necessities.
Socialism-Socialism is based on the premise that people will be compensated based on their level of individual contribution to the economy. Additionally effort and innovation are thus rewarded under socialism.
Communism-In communism, a violent revolution where workers rise up against the middle class and upper class is seen as an inevitable part of achieving a pure-communist state.
Socialism-Socialism seeks change and reform through democratic processes within the existing social and political structure.

Use the table to compare and contrast the information about communism and socialism. Using your findings, plan a media product that describes the similarities and differences between socialism and communism. Your plan should include an outline, draft, or storyboard, as well as steps for implementing your plan. Be sure to end your media product with a defensible position about whether you think communism and socialism are more similar or more different. Finally, describe your media product and your final argument in at least one paragraph.

Comparison of communism and socialism:

Plan for a media product about the similarities and differences of socialism and communism:

Paragraph describing the media product and your final argument on whether communism and socialism are more similar or different:

Answer the 3 parts above.

Answer 1

Comparison of Communism and Socialism

| Features | Communism | Socialism | |----------------------------|--------------------------------------------------|----------------------------------------| | Purpose | Eliminate worker exploitation | Limit worker exploitation | | Class Structure | Aim to eliminate economic classes | Aim to lower influence of economic classes | | Ownership | No private property | Allows individual property ownership | | Production | Government controls all goods/services | Public ownership of key industries/services | | Compensation | Based on government-assumed needs | Based on individual contribution | | Revolution | Advocates for violent revolution | Seeks change through democratic processes |

Plan for a Media Product about the Similarities and Differences of Socialism and Communism

Outline

1. Introduction

   • Define socialism and communism.
   • Introduce the purpose of the media product.

2. Similarities

   • Discuss the purpose of eliminating worker exploitation.
   • Examine the goal of reducing the influence of economic classes.
   • Highlight the concept of collective ownership in production.

3. Differences

   • Contrast private property rights in socialism vs. communism.
   • Discuss differences in compensation structures.
   • Address the role of revolution vs. reform.

4. Conclusion

   • Summarize key points.
   • Present a defensible position regarding the similarities and differences.

Format

• Medium: Informative video/documentary (5-7 minutes in length)

• Visual Elements:

  • Graphics comparing features side by side.
  • Footage or animations illustrating key concepts.

• Audio Elements:

  • Narration for clarity.
  • Background music to enhance engagement.

• Interviews:

  • Experts discussing the implications of socialism and communism in modern society.

Steps for Implementing the Plan

1. Research: Conduct thorough research to gather more data and expert opinions on socialism and communism.
2. Scriptwriting: Write a detailed script following the outline, ensuring each point is explained clearly.
3. Storyboarding: Create a storyboard that illustrates how visuals will align with the narration.
4. Production: Film and edit the video. Utilize animations and graphics to help illustrate complex concepts.
5. Feedback: Show a draft version to peers to gather feedback, adjusting elements as needed.
6. Final Edit: Make final adjustments based on feedback and prepare for distribution.
7. Distribution: Share the video on platforms such as YouTube, educational websites, and social media to reach the target audience.

Paragraph Describing the Media Product and Final Argument

The media product will be a 5-7 minute informative video that visually and audibly explains the similarities and differences between socialism and communism. The video will effectively outline their foundational goals of diminishing worker exploitation and class disparity while contrasting their approaches, particularly concerning private property rights and compensation methods. The conclusion will assert that while socialism and communism share similar foundational goals and ideologies regarding economic equality and collective ownership, they are fundamentally different in how they propose to achieve these aims. Socialism prioritizes democratic reform and individual property rights, while communism envisions a radical overhaul of society through revolution and the abolition of private property. Therefore, despite their overlapping intentions, communism and socialism are more different than they are similar, as their methods of attaining equality and the value placed on private property set them apart significantly.