The poem "What Love Isn’t" presents a raw and unfiltered perspective on love, depicting it as something substantial and often uncomfortable, rather than idealized or superficial. It emphasizes that love is not about luxury or flattery, but rather a solid, sometimes gritty experience that can be heavy and surprising. In contrast to the poem, Shakespeare's portrayal of love in "Romeo and Juliet" often aligns with the intense emotions and challenges depicted, as the characters experience profound passion that leads to both joy and tragedy. However, while Shakespeare does highlight the sincerity of their love, he also imbues it with a romantic idealism that romanticizes their fate rather than focusing solely on the weighty complexities of love described in the poem. Therefore, while there are elements in common, Shakespeare would likely appreciate the poem's acknowledgment of love's difficulties, yet he ultimately presents a more hopeful narrative about love's power to transcend even the most turbulent challenges.
Romeo and Juliet Extra Credit:
YOUR TASK: Make a copy of this document! Read the following poem and answer the question in a long, detailed paragraph. This extra credit is worth 10 points on a test.
the poem is called what love isn't
starts with
it is not a five star stay. it is not compliments and it is never ever flattery
it is solid. not sweet but always nutritious
always herb, always salt sometimes grit
it is now and till the end it is never a slither, never a little
it is a full serving
it is much
too much nd real
never pretty or clean. it stinks you can smell it comin
it is weight
it is weight and it is too heavy to feel good sometimes it is discomfort it is not what the films say only songs get it right
it is irregular it is difficult and always always suprising
SUMMARIZE this poem. Based on this poem’s definition of love, would Shakespeare agree with this definition? WHY or WHY NOT? Think of the events of Romeo and Juliet to back up your argument!
and please make it only 5 sentances
3 answers
The poem "What Love Isn't" offers a stark and realistic definition of love, describing it as substantial, often uncomfortable, and filled with unexpected challenges. It contrasts idealized notions of romance by emphasizing that love is not about flattery or luxury but about a deep, gritty connection. In "Romeo and Juliet," Shakespeare does portray love as intense and complicated, showcasing both its beauty and its burdens. However, he often leans toward a more romanticized vision, highlighting love's transcendent power, even amid suffering. Therefore, while Shakespeare recognizes love's complexities, he may not entirely agree with the poem's definition, as he also embraces an idealistic view of love's ultimate significance.
1 answer