The distinctions between Arnold Friend and Charles Schmid are far more ominous, as Arnold conceals a darker secret. While both characters wore boots, Arnold's hidden truth is more malevolent than Smitty's. Joyce Carol Oates illustrates this when she writes, “He wobbled in his high boots and grabbed hold of one of the porch posts” (Oates 10). This detail suggests that Arnold Friend lacks feet, a characteristic that further associates him with the devil. Additionally, Arnold has an unsettling awareness of everything happening in town; Oates states, “Sitting around,” he said vaguely, squinting as if he were staring all the way to town...” (Oates 10). This implies that he eerily knows what Connie’s family is up to, reinforcing his portrayal as a devilish figure. These elements highlight how the villains differ more than they align.
The similarities and differences between Arnold Friend and Charles Schmid indicate that Arnold's character was inspired by Schmid, further supporting the notion that Arnold Friend is based on Charles Schmid.