Refuting the idea that the Moon would be destroyed if it got too close to Earth requires challenging either the validity of the Roche limit principle in this context or the specific application of the calculations involved:
1. **Reevaluation of the Roche Limit for a Rigid Body:**
- The Roche limit you provided applies to fluid bodies, meaning bodies without significant tensile strength. The Moon, however, is mostly solid rock and has considerable internal cohesion. For rigid bodies, the Roche limit is closer, and this could change the dynamic significantly.
- A more appropriate Roche limit for rigid bodies is given by a different set of equations that considers the tensile strength of the materials. The rigid-body Roche limit would be much closer than 18,470 km, indicating that the Moon would not necessarily disintegrate at the calculated Roche limit for fluid bodies.
2. **Controlled Approach within the Limit:**
- Suppose the Moon approached Earth while maintaining its structural integrity. It is plausible that the Moon could interact gravitationally in a way that slows or reverses its approach before reaching the rigid Roche limit, thanks to complex gravitational interactions between Earth and Moon, plus orbital dynamics involving both celestial bodies.
3. **Historical and Other Observational Evidence:**
- Throughout history, there is evidence of celestial bodies (such as large asteroids or dwarf planets) undergoing close encounters with planets of the Solar System without disintegrating. While these cases might involve smaller bodies, they suggest that the dynamics of close approaches can be more complicated than a straightforward application of the Roche limit might imply.
4. **Simplified Estimation Concerns:**
- Simplifying assumptions in calculating the Roche limit (e.g., uniform density) might not fully capture the Moon’s behavior given its complex structure. Actual celestial bodies are not perfectly uniform and may have varying densities, composition, and structural integrity throughout, which affect their disintegration threshold.
5. **Influence of Other Forces and Effects:**
- Other forces, including Earth's atmosphere drag (though thin at high altitudes), angular momentum transfer, or rotational dynamics of both Earth and Moon also play crucial roles. These factors are often neglected in a simple Roche limit calculation but can significantly alter the outcome.
By considering these points, one can argue that the immediate disintegration of the Moon if it got within a certain distance of Earth might be an oversimplification. The real-world scenario would likely involve a much more complex interplay of forces and dynamics, potentially preventing the Moon’s disintegration at or even within the predicted Roche limit for fluid bodies.
refute this
The concept that the moon would be destroyed if it got too close to Earth is grounded in the Roche limit, a principle in celestial mechanics. The Roche limit is the minimum distance at which a celestial body, due to tidal forces, would disintegrate due to the gravitational forces exerted by a larger body exceeding the smaller body's gravitational self-attraction. Here's an explanation:
The Roche limit is determined by the densities of the two celestial bodies. For a moon made of solid rock orbiting a planet like Earth, the Roche limit can be roughly calculated using the formula:
[ d = 2.44 R \left( \frac{\rho_p}{\rho_m} \right)^{1/3} ]
Where:
( d ) is the Roche limit distance.
( R ) is the radius of the larger body (Earth).
( \rho_p ) is the density of the larger body (Earth).
( \rho_m ) is the density of the smaller body (Moon).
For the Earth-Moon system:
Earth's radius (( R )) is approximately 6,371 km.
Earth's density (( \rho_p )) is approximately 5.52 g/cm³.
Moon's density (( \rho_m )) is approximately 3.34 g/cm³.
Plugging these values into the formula gives an approximate Roche limit distance of about 18,470 km from the Earth's center. The current average distance of the Moon from Earth is about 384,400 km, well beyond the Roche limit.
If the Moon were to somehow move within this Roche limit distance, the tidal forces exerted by Earth's gravity would exceed the Moon's gravitational self-attraction. This would cause the Moon to experience extreme tidal stresses, leading to its fragmentation and eventual disintegration into smaller pieces. These fragments could form a ring system around Earth, similar to those seen around other planets like Saturn.
In summary, the principle of the Roche limit explains why a celestial body like the Moon would be destroyed if it came too close to Earth, due to the overwhelming tidal forces breaking it apart.
1 answer