Read this example.

Question

Jordan is given this writing prompt in class:

Write a personal narrative essay that describes a significant experience with a family member that has shaped your identity.

Jordan decides that he is going to write a letter to his cousin Andre to thank Andre for helping him write music and develop his talent as a musician.

Which statement best describes Jordan’s response to the writing prompt?

Jordan’s topic is acceptable, but it is not in the correct format.
Jordan’s topic is not acceptable, because it is not a significant experience.
Jordan’s topic is not acceptable, because it is not an experience with a family member.
Jordan’s topic and format are both acceptable, because they carefully follow the prompt.

Answer 1

The best statement that describes Jordan’s response to the writing prompt is:

Jordan’s topic and format are both acceptable, because they carefully follow the prompt.

Jordan is writing about a significant experience with his cousin Andre, who is a family member, and he is expressing gratitude in a letter format, which aligns with the narrative aspect of the prompt.