Read "The Workers of Ellis Island"; and look at the photo.

Question

Three men standing behind a seated man. The first man is wearing all black with a white collar. The second man is wearing a white shirt with a black jacket. The third man is wearing all white.

Which statement is most likely accurate?

The man on the left works as a surgeon at Ellis Island.
The man who is standing in the center is a clerk at Ellis Island.
The man who is sitting recently received medical attention.
The man on the right has traveled from a foreign country.
help

Answer 1

Based on the description of the photograph you provided, here’s an analysis of each statement:

1. The man on the left works as a surgeon at Ellis Island. - This may be possible if his all-black attire with a white collar aligns with the attire of medical professionals, but without specific context, we cannot confirm this with certainty.

2. The man who is standing in the center is a clerk at Ellis Island. - This statement could be plausible if the man's attire (a white shirt with a black jacket) is typical for clerical work during the era depicted.

3. The man who is sitting recently received medical attention. - This could be true if, for example, he appears to be in need of care or if there are contextual clues suggesting he just underwent a medical examination.

4. The man on the right has traveled from a foreign country. - This statement is often true for individuals at Ellis Island since it served as an immigration station, but without specific identifiers, this is more ambiguous.

Given the context of Ellis Island as a place associated with immigration and medical inspections, and the way you've described the men, the most accurate statement would likely be:

The man on the right has traveled from a foreign country.

This conclusion follows logically since Ellis Island was primarily known for receiving immigrants.