Question

Question

Consider two examples of cultural boundaries you have studied.



A. In 2–3 sentences, describe how these cultural boundaries were established.



B. In 2–3 sentences, provide further description of these boundaries, including any information you have about the way in which these boundaries have been defined, delimited, demarcated, and administered. Consider, also, the responses of the parties affected by the boundary.



C. Using these descriptions, analyze your examples in 2–3 sentences. Which one would you argue is the “better” boundary? Support your assertion with specific information from your descriptions.

(4 points)
write like a 9th grader

Answer 1

A. One example of a cultural boundary is the border between India and Pakistan, which was established during the partition of British India in 1947. This division was based largely on religious differences, as India was predominantly Hindu and Pakistan was created as a Muslim-majority state.

B. The border between India and Pakistan is defined by the Radcliffe Line and has been demarcated through various agreements and conflicts. It has led to significant tensions, including wars and ongoing disputes over regions like Kashmir. Both countries have different responses to this boundary, with Pakistan claiming Kashmir and India asserting its control, leading to military presence and frequent skirmishes in the area.

C. I would argue that the India-Pakistan boundary is a “better” boundary compared to other examples, like the Berlin Wall, because it reflects significant cultural and religious differences that were present at the time of partition. While it has led to conflict, at least the boundary was based on the identities of the people living there, whereas the Berlin Wall separated communities without regard for the cultural ties between families and friends.