PETROCELLI

Withdrawn. Mr. Harmon, you say you weren't at the drugstore anytime during the day of the robbery. Perhaps you would tell us where you were.

STEVE

I don't know exactly where I was when the robbery took place. Most of the day I was going around taking mental notes about places I wanted to film for a school film project.

PETROCELLI

Well, if you don't know exactly where you were, can you tell me anyone who might know where you were?

STEVE

I don't even remember where I was. When the detectives asked me where I was, I couldn't even remember the day they were talking about. They didn't ask me about it until weeks later.

PETROCELLI

Then how do you remember – what did you say? – taking mental notes for a school film project?

STEVE

I know that because I was planning to do the film of my neighborhood over the holidays.

—Monster,
Walter Dean Myers

Based on this passage and the rest of what you’ve read in Monster, do you think Steve is telling the truth on the witness stand? Explain.

1 answer

In the passage from Monster by Walter Dean Myers, Steve Harmon offers a somewhat ambiguous account of his whereabouts during the robbery. While he admits that he cannot recall exactly where he was, he provides a detail about taking mental notes for a school film project, suggesting that he had some intentions or plans for the day. However, he also mentions that he struggled to remember details when questioned by detectives weeks after the event, which raises questions about the reliability of his memory and his ability to recount specific information.

Determining whether Steve is telling the truth on the witness stand involves considering his credibility and the circumstances surrounding the incident. On one hand, it's plausible that Steve is honest in his assertion that he was preoccupied with his project and genuinely cannot remember the precise details of what he was doing. On the other hand, his inability to corroborate his story with a specific location or other witnesses may lead some to doubt his truthfulness.

Additionally, the context of the trial and Steve's situation as a young black male accused of serious crimes can influence perceptions of his credibility. The pressure and anxiety associated with being in court could also affect his recollection of events. Overall, while he presents himself as truthful in his intentions and experience, the lack of concrete evidence to support his alibi casts doubt on his account, leaving room for a reader to question whether he is telling the full truth or merely trying to distance himself from the crime.