The first attempt was more successful because the settlers built a lasting settlement at Charlesfort.
This reflects the initial French effort to establish a colony in South Carolina in the 1560s, where they founded Charlesfort on Parris Island. Although this settlement ultimately did not thrive long-term due to various challenges, it represented an early and significant French presence in the region. The second attempt, involving the Huguenots in the late 17th century, faced different challenges and was less established compared to the initial effort.