THE GIVER — Chapter 14 (Pages 136-148)
DURING READING QUESTIONS STUDENT RESPONSE
1. Why does Jonas experience leg pain even after he is finished receiving the memory? [RL 7.1]
Jonas feels leg pain because the memories he receives are so intense and affect him physically. Even when the memory fades, the pain and feelings linger, showing how deeply the experiences impact him. It's like having a really bad dream – even when you wake up, you still feel a bit scared or off.
2. What does The Giver’s story about the last time he gave advice to the Committee of Elders reveal about The Giver and The Committee’s different points of view toward the lost pilot? [RL 7.6]
The Giver and the Committee see things very differently. The Giver understands the pain and loss that comes from memories of the past, like the pilot's story. In contrast, the Committee seems more focused on rules and maintaining order, showing how they lack empathy. It's like The Giver carries the emotional weight of history, while the Committee avoids it to keep everything "perfect."
3. A: What does the excerpt reveal about Jonas as a character? [RL 7.3]
In this excerpt, Jonas shows that he is empathetic and cares about others. He thinks it would be easier if everyone shared the burden of memories. This demonstrates his growing awareness of how lonely it is to be the only one with emotional experiences. It illustrates his wish for connection and understanding among all people.
4. What does Jonas’s mother’s unwillingness to wake up in the middle of the night to comfort Gabe reveal about her as a character? [RL 7.3]
It shows that Jonas's mother is practical and prioritizes her own needs over those of Gabriel. She is probably tired and just wants to sleep, which suggests she might not fully grasp the emotional needs of her children, including Jonas and Gabe. It makes us question how much she understands about love and caring for children.
5. Why does Jonas hope that Larissa is the one who will be there to take care of the twin who is going to be released to Elsewhere? [RL 7.1]
Jonas hopes Larissa will be there because he feels she is compassionate and understanding. He trusts her more than others, which reflects his desire for someone gentle to take care of the situation instead of the coldness of the community's practices. It shows his longing for kindness in a harsh world.
6. How does accidentally giving a memory to Gabe affect Jonas? [RL 7.3]
Accidentally giving a memory to Gabe leaves Jonas confused and concerned because it means that the memories are not just his to keep. It makes him realize that memories are powerful and can impact others, which increases his sense of responsibility. There’s a mix of connection and worry for him, showing that his feelings are becoming more complex.
End of Chapter Discussion Questions
7. How might the past’s famine and destruction have contributed to the community’s current structure? Should Jonas turn himself in to The Giver and confess that he gave a memory to Gabe? Why or why not?
The past’s famine and destruction probably shaped the community’s strict rules to avoid chaos and suffering. They focus on sameness and control. As for Jonas confessing, he might feel guilty but turning himself in could also put him in danger. He should think about the larger picture – if revealing it helps the community see the value of emotions, then maybe he should. But it’s also a huge risk.
Independent Practice
1. What is the best meaning of “befit” as it is used in the following sentence on page 145? [RL 7.4]
A. suited
2. Which of the following options best represents the way this community as a whole views babies? [RL 7.1 & RL 7.6]
A. Maintaining an orderly community is more important than any individual baby.
3. Which sentence from the passage above best explains Jonas’s reason for deciding to give the entire sailboat memory to Gabriel? [RL 7.1]
D. “Gabriel became quiet.”
THE GIVER — Chapters 15-16 (Pages 149-162)
DURING READING QUESTIONS STUDENT RESPONSE
1. A: How does possessing all of the memories of the past affect The Giver? [RL 7.3]
The Giver feels heavy and burdened because he carries so much pain and sadness from past experiences. It isolates him because he understands feelings that others do not.
2. How does the author’s use of color enhance the description of what Jonas experiences? [RL 7.4]
The colors described give life to the memories, making them feel more real and intense. For instance, the brightness of the colors contrasted with the carnage shows the horrific beauty of life and death intertwined.
3. A: How does the author’s use of auditory imagery help show what war is truly like? [RL 7.4]
The sounds of battle – cries, horses, and cannons – make the memory come alive and show the chaos and terror of war. It doesn’t just tell us; it makes us feel the horror of what it was like.
4. A: How does experiencing warfare affect Jonas’s attitude toward receiving memories? [RL 7.6]
After witnessing the brutality of war, Jonas sees memories as something heavy and painful. He's more aware of the cost of knowing the truth, and it makes him feel hesitant and scared about what other memories might hold.
5. How does experiencing the memory of a family celebrating Christmas change the way Jonas views his community? [RL 7.6]
It makes Jonas realize what his community is missing – love, warmth, and the joy of family connections. It shows that their way of life might be safe, but it lacks true happiness and emotion, which he starts to crave.
Independent Practice
1. What is the best meaning of “grotesquely” as it is used in the following sentence on page 150? [RL 7.4]
D. sickeningly
2. Which option best describes the meaning of the phrase “a dull blankness slid slowly across his eyes”? [RL 7.4]
D. The soldier’s eyes glazed over as he died.
3. In Chapter 16 Jonas experiences a memory of love. Which of the following pieces of evidence best supports the theme that having love is worth the chance of being hurt? [RL 7.1]
C. “He could feel that there was risk involved […] ‘Still,’ he said slowly, almost to himself, ‘I did like the light they made. And the warmth.’”
THE GIVER — Chapter 17 (Pages 163-173)
DURING READING QUESTIONS STUDENT RESPONSE
1. What does this excerpt reveal about Jonas as a character? [RL 7.3]
It shows that Jonas is deep and thoughtful. He understands that sadness is real and can't just be brushed aside like everything else in his community. He is growing emotionally and realizes some feelings are too important to ignore.
2. What does Jonas’s reaction to the game of war reveal about his and Asher’s different points of view? [RL 7.6]
Jonas takes the concept of war seriously, while Asher treats it like a joke or game. This shows how Jonas has a deeper understanding of the implications of violence and conflict, and that he’s becoming disconnected from his friends’ perspectives.
3. Why does Jonas turn down Fiona’s offer to ride bikes by the river? [RL 7.6]
He turns her down because he’s struggling with feelings and issues that his friends don’t understand. It highlights how he’s changing and becoming more aware of the complexities of his feelings, separating him from the carefree life he once had.
4. Why does Jonas ask his father for details about the process of releasing a newchild? [RL 7.1]
Jonas asks because he's starting to question what "release" really means, especially after learning about the harsh realities behind it. He wants to understand why it’s done and what it involves, showing his growing discomfort with the community's practices.
End of Chapter Discussion Questions
How would you feel if you knew something that you couldn’t tell your friends?
It would be super lonely and frustrating! I would feel like I'm carrying this huge weight on my shoulders all the time. It’s hard to keep stuff like that inside without being able to talk to someone about it.
Who would you rather have as a friend: Jonas or Asher? Why?
I’d probably pick Jonas because he seems more thoughtful and really cares about deeper feelings, while Asher feels more shallow and goofy. I think having a friend who understands you on a deeper level is more valuable than just someone who makes you laugh.