Mrs Y is a retired advocate and a resident of Wisteria House, a private retirement and care facility. Mrs Y lives in the care facility as she has trouble walking and many of the other residents also require assisted living. One day, while Mrs Y was slowly walking to her room, an orderly came walking up behind her, very fast and when he could not pass her, he shoved her against a wall and said "move idiot”." She was shocked and when she later told some of the other ladies in her bingo group what had happened, they all had similar stories. Mrs Y then started the "Take care of the Elders Association" who lodged numerous complaints to Wisteria House's management.

Question

Nothina came of these complaints and as such Mrs Y decides that she has to stand up for herself and the other verv sicklv residents and is aoina to approach the Constitutional Court as she feels that this is a violation of manv constitutional rights including the right to bodily autonomy.
1.On what grounds may Mrs Y have standing to approach the Court?
2.Other than the Constitutional Court, who could Mrs Y approach for help?
For the toolbar, press ALT+F10 (PC) or

Answer 1

1. Standing to Approach the Court: Mrs. Y may have standing to approach the Constitutional Court on several grounds:

   • Personal Interest: As a direct victim of the actions of the orderly, Mrs. Y has a personal interest in the matter and sufficient grounds to claim that her rights were violated. This could include rights to dignity, bodily integrity, safety, and freedom from degrading treatment, which are often protected under constitutional law.

   • Public Interest: By founding the "Take Care of the Elders Association", Mrs. Y could also argue that she represents a broader interest affecting other vulnerable residents of Wisteria House. As such, she may have standing as a representative of a class of persons whose rights are similarly affected.

   • Advocacy on Behalf of Others: Many courts recognize that individuals can bring cases not just for themselves, but on behalf of others. Since Mrs. Y has gathered testimonies from other residents with similar experiences, this could strengthen her standing and provide a basis for collective legal action.

2. Other Avenues for Help:

   • Ombudsman: Mrs. Y could approach an Ombudsman or similar oversight body that addresses complaints regarding the treatment of residents in care facilities. They can investigate complaints and recommend actions.

   • Legal Aid Services: Local legal aid organizations may provide assistance in filing a lawsuit or help with navigating the complaint process in a more accessible manner.

   • Human Rights Commission: Depending on the country, there may be a human rights commission where she could lodge a complaint regarding the treatment of elderly individuals, potentially launching an investigation.

   • Media Publicity: Engaging local media could help amplify her concerns and the issues faced by residents, potentially prompting action from management or authorities.

   • Advocacy Groups: There are many organizations dedicated to the rights of the elderly and vulnerable populations that may offer support, legal advice, or assistance in organizing collective actions.

By pursuing these avenues, Mrs. Y may find additional support and resources to address the issues at Wisteria House.