To determine who is correct between Jerome's brother and sister, we first need to analyze the ratios presented in Jerome's original mixture and how they change based on their suggestions.
Original Mixture:
Jerome uses:
- Water = 8 cups
- Drink Mix = 3 cups
Finding the Ratios:
-
Part-to-Part Ratio (Water to Drink Mix): \[ \text{Water : Drink Mix} = 8 : 3 \] This means for every 8 cups of water, there are 3 cups of drink mix.
-
Part-to-Whole Ratio (Water to Total Mixture): \[ \text{Total Mixture} = \text{Water} + \text{Drink Mix} = 8 + 3 = 11 \text{ cups} \] So, \[ \text{Water : Total Mixture} = 8 : 11 \]
Analyzing Suggestions:
1. Jerome's Brother's Suggestion:
Jerome's brother suggests to add one cup of water for every one cup of drink mix added.
If Jerome adds 1 cup of drink mix:
- New amount of Drink Mix = \(3 + 1 = 4\) cups
- New amount of Water = \(8 + 1 = 9\) cups
This results in:
- New Ratio (Water : Drink Mix) = \(9 : 4\)
Analysis:
The new ratio \(9 : 4\) is not equivalent to the original ratio \(8 : 3\) (since \( \frac{9}{4} \neq \frac{8}{3} \)). Therefore, Jerome's brother's suggestion does not keep the ratio the same.
2. Jerome's Sister's Suggestion:
Jerome's sister suggests to multiply both the amount of water and the drink mix by the same number.
Let's say Jerome wants to double the amounts:
- New Water = \(8 \times 2 = 16\) cups
- New Drink Mix = \(3 \times 2 = 6\) cups
This results in:
- New Ratio (Water : Drink Mix) = \(16 : 6\)
- Simplified Ratio = \(8 : 3\)
Analysis:
The new ratio \(16 : 6\) simplifies back to the original ratio \(8 : 3\). Therefore, Jerome's sister's suggestion keeps the ratio the same.
Conclusion:
Jerome's sister is correct. By multiplying both the amount of water and the drink mix by the same number, the ratio remains consistent with the original 8:3 ratio (water to drink mix). Jerome’s brother’s method, on the other hand, changes the ratio and does not maintain the original proportions necessary for his energy drink.
Final Judgement:
Jerome should follow Jerome's sister's advice if he wants to increase the total amount of energy drink while preserving the same flavor consistency and strength of the original blend.