MAKE A COPY Research information on two public issues. You may choose public issues discussed in the lesson or choose a different one of interest to you. Collect sources and evaluate the credibility and accuracy of each source.

Question

Complete the checklist from the lesson when accessing and evaluating sources.
5
6
Public Issue
Source
Credibility Rating
Credentials
Bias Evaluation
Date of Article

Question 2

Your state government has enacted a policy that requires a mask to be worn in public at all times to prevent future pandemics and the spread of communicable diseases. In the role of a private citizen, take a position on this new policy and defend it. Evaluate several credible resources to gather reasoning that supports your position on this nolicv
Source
Credibility Rating
Bias Evaluation
What evidence from the source helped you determine the position of the source? List a quote or sentence from the source to support

Answer 1

Public Issue Research

Public Issue 1: Climate Change

| Source | Credibility Rating | Credentials | Bias Evaluation | Date of Article | |---------------------------------------------------------|--------------------|-------------------------------|-------------------------------------|-----------------------| | Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) Report | High | International climate experts | Mostly neutral, peer-reviewed | 2022 | | NASA Climate Change and Global Warming | High | NASA scientists and researchers| Mainly factual, educational | Updated 2023 |

Public Issue 2: Gun Control Legislation

| Source | Credibility Rating | Credentials | Bias Evaluation | Date of Article | |---------------------------------------------------------|--------------------|-------------------------------|-------------------------------------|-----------------------| | The Pew Research Center | High | Credible research institution | Neutral, statistical analysis | 2021 | | The American Journal of Public Health | High | Peer-reviewed public health journal | Mostly neutral, review-based | 2022 |

---

Evaluation of State Mask Policy

As a private citizen, I support the policy requiring masks to be worn in public to prevent future pandemics and the spread of communicable diseases. Here are the evaluated credible resources that bolster my position:

| Source | Credibility Rating | Bias Evaluation | Evidence Supporting Position | |---------------------------------------------------------|--------------------|-------------------------------------|-------------------------------------| | Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) | High | Primarily factual, authoritative | "Wearing masks helps prevent the spread of respiratory diseases." | | World Health Organization (WHO) | High | Scientific and neutral | "Masks are a critical tool in the fight against COVID-19." |

Evidence from Resources

1. CDC Source

   • Quote: "Wearing masks helps prevent the spread of respiratory diseases."
   • Analysis: This statement directly supports the effectiveness of mask-wearing as a public health measure, establishing a clear rationale for the state policy.

2. WHO Source

   • Quote: "Masks are a critical tool in the fight against COVID-19."
   • Analysis: This reinforces the argument by highlighting the importance of masks, especially during health crises, showcasing that the policy is grounded in established public health practices.

Conclusion

The requirement for masks to be worn in public can help safeguard community health, minimize the transmission of infectious diseases, and prevent future pandemics based on credible evidence provided by reputable sources.