Major themes in literature often relate back to the idea of "good vs. evil." For example, in novels you can often find a brave hero facing off against a wicked villain to teach the reader that being good and

Question

doing the right thing is what is best for society. These stories usually show the hero as being all good and the villain as being all bad, and the choice to do the right thing is always very clear. However, how
does this apply to the real world?
The article, "A teen and a trolley reveal society's dark side," explores this debate. Examine the article and determine whether you believe that people can be completely good or whether you think there is a
dark side to us all. Explain your reasoning.
Post a detailed response to the Trolley Discussion prompt.

Answer 1

In the article, "A teen and a trolley reveal society's dark side," the author discusses a thought experiment in which participants are asked to make a decision about whether it is morally acceptable to sacrifice one person in order to save five others from a deadly trolley accident. The article highlights the moral dilemma faced by individuals when forced to make difficult choices that involve sacrificing one life for the greater good.

This brings to light the idea that people are not always purely good or purely evil, but rather exist on a spectrum of morality. In the context of the trolley dilemma, individuals may be faced with conflicting principles and values that shape their decision-making process. While some may argue that sacrificing one life to save five is the morally right decision, others may struggle with the idea of intentionally causing harm to another individual, regardless of the outcome.

This complexity in human morality goes beyond the simplistic portrayal of good vs. evil that is often found in literature. It suggests that individuals are capable of both altruistic and morally questionable actions, depending on the circumstances and their own personal beliefs.

I believe that there is a dark side to all individuals, as we are inherently flawed and influenced by a multitude of factors that can cloud our judgment. While we may strive to do good and make ethical decisions, we are susceptible to biases, emotions, and external pressures that can lead us astray. It is important to acknowledge and confront this dark side within ourselves in order to make more conscious and responsible choices in the real world.