In both "The Moustache" by Robert Cormier and "The Catcher in the Rye" by J.D. Salinger, the protagonists grapple with their identities during the tumultuous period of adolescence. Michael, in Cormier's narrative, uses his moustache as a symbol of maturity and independence, while simultaneously exploring the expectations and judgments that accompany physical appearance. His decision to grow a moustache becomes a means of asserting his identity, but it also opens up a deeper conversation about how others perceive him—an issue that many adolescents face as they transition from childhood to adulthood.
Similarly, Holden Caulfield in "The Catcher in the Rye" navigates his identity crisis against a backdrop of societal expectations and the phony nature he perceives in adults. Holden's disdain for the adult world reflects his struggle to find authenticity in a society that often feels insincere. The insecurities and confusion that both Michael and Holden experience highlight the common theme of adolescent identity formation.
Both characters confront the tension between their self-perception and how others view them. Michael’s moustache serves as a physical manifestation of his quest for identity, while Holden’s aloofness and cynicism illustrate his desperate search for meaning in a confusing world. Ultimately, both narratives emphasize the profound impact of societal perception on personal identity, revealing how adolescence is marked by a delicate balance between self-discovery and the desire for acceptance. Through their journeys, Michael and Holden embody the universal challenges of growing up, as they strive to assert their identities amidst the conflicting messages from the world around them.