In the crucible act 4

Question

Why did she just lie? What is she trying to do?
A. She knows he confessed and wants him to hang.

B. She doesn't know he confessed, so she's trying to protect her husband.

C. She and Abigail are secretly in on it together and planned this to get back at John.

Answer 1

In Act 4 of "The Crucible," the character Elizabeth Proctor lies about her husband's affair with Abigail Williams when she is questioned. The best explanation from the options provided is:

B. She doesn't know he confessed, so she's trying to protect her husband.

Elizabeth is attempting to protect John Proctor's reputation and integrity, demonstrating her loyalty and love for him. She is unaware that John has already confessed to the affair in a previous act, believing that her lie would serve to shield him from further shame. Her action ultimately reflects the tragic dynamics of the relationships and the complex moral choices the characters face in the oppressive environment of the Salem witch trials.