In Chapter 5 of "Lord of the Flies," which is titled "Beast from Water," Ralph, Piggy, and Simon engage in a discussion about the existence and nature of the beast that the boys fear on the island. This chapter marks a turning point in their understanding of the beast.
Ralph expresses frustration about the fear of the beast, noting that they need to focus on maintaining the signal fire and being rescued. Piggy supports Ralph and argues that the beast is just a figment of their imagination and doesn't exist. He emphasizes the importance of reason and rationality in the face of fear.
On the other hand, Simon presents a more introspective view. He suggests that the beast may not be an external creature but rather something innate within themselves, hinting at the darkness and savagery that can emerge in humanity. This idea foreshadows the themes of inherent human evil that are central to the novel.
Overall, this discussion reflects the boys' increasing descent into savagery and their struggle between civilization and their primal instincts.