Virginia Woolf's decision to create a hypothetical sister for William Shakespeare, named Judith, serves as a poignant rhetorical device in her essay "A Room of One's Own." By imagining a talented female counterpart to an illustrious male figure, Woolf underscores the systemic barriers that women faced in pursuing their creative ambitions. Judith Shakespeare embodies the lost potential of countless women throughout history whose talents went unrecognized and unfulfilled due to societal constraints. Woolf illustrates how Judith, despite her brilliance and innate abilities, would be stifled by societal expectations, limited access to education, and the oppressive norms of her time, ultimately leading to her tragic fate. This construction allows Woolf to highlight the inequalities in women's opportunities for artistic expression and the dire consequences of a patriarchal society that stifles female voices.
Focusing on a hypothetical character like Judith effectively amplifies Woolf's argument about the necessity of acknowledging women's contributions to literature and society. By crafting a narrative around Judith's struggles, Woolf not only humanizes the issue but also evokes empathy from her readers, emphasizing that the loss of brilliant women is not merely an abstract concept but a tangible tragedy. Judith's plight illustrates the broader implications of gender inequality, making Woolf’s argument resonate on both an emotional and an intellectual level. However, it could also be argued that relying on a fictional character might distance some readers from the very real struggles faced by women of Woolf's time. Still, in the context of her broader feminist discourse, Judith serves as a compelling emblem of lost possibilities, powerfully reinforcing Woolf’s call for women to claim their space and voice in the literary canon.