To distinguish between plagioclase and quartz, you can use several methods based on their physical properties. Here are some techniques:
-
Hardness Test: The Mohs scale of mineral hardness can be helpful. Quartz has a hardness of about 7, while plagioclase has a hardness of about 6-6.5. You can perform a scratch test using a metal object or another mineral. If the crystal can scratch the object, it is likely quartz. If the object can scratch the crystal, it may be plagioclase.
-
Cleavage vs. Fracture: Plagioclase has distinct cleavage and will break along planes, while quartz has a conchoidal fracture with no cleavage. Examine the surfaces of the crystals. If you see flat, shiny surfaces, you’re likely looking at plagioclase; if the surfaces are smooth and curve, it's likely quartz.
-
Luster: While both minerals can have a vitreous luster, plagioclase may show a more pearly or dull appearance, especially if weathered. Compare the luster of both crystals under a light source.
-
Transparency and Color: Both crystals can be colorless and transparent, but plagioclase crystals may show a slight opalescence or a white, cloudy appearance due to the presence of fine inclusions. Examine the clarity and color closely.
-
Twining: Some plagioclase crystals exhibit twinning, particularly if you look at them under a polarized light microscope. If you're in a lab setting, you could use a simple polarized light test to see if you can identify the characteristic twinning of plagioclase.
-
Acid Test: Quartz does not react to hydrochloric acid, while some plagioclase may show a slight reaction, especially if it contains small amounts of other minerals. However, this is a less common method for distinguishing these two minerals.
Combining observations from these methods will give you a strong indication of which crystal is quartz and which is plagioclase. Always take care when handling the crystals and perform any tests safely.
75 answers