The statement that best captures the difference between the religious beliefs of the Puritans and those of other English colonists is: The Puritans desired an even more reformed version of Protestantism.
Puritans sought to "purify" the Church of England from any remnants of Catholicism and wanted a more rigorous and austere form of worship, while other English colonists, such as those in Jamestown, may have adhered to more traditional Anglican practices.