To find the original price of each leotard, we first need to calculate how much Harper saved on each leotard.
Harper bought 2 leotards and saved a total of $22.38. Since she saved the same amount on each leotard, we can find the amount she saved on one leotard by dividing the total savings by the number of leotards:
\[ \text{Savings per leotard} = \frac{\text{Total Savings}}{\text{Number of leotards}} = \frac{22.38}{2} = 11.19 \]
Now we know that Harper saved $11.19 on each leotard. Since she bought each leotard for $24.80, we can find the original price of each leotard by adding the savings back to the sale price:
\[ \text{Original Price} = \text{Sale Price} + \text{Savings per leotard} = 24.80 + 11.19 \]
Calculating this gives:
\[ \text{Original Price} = 24.80 + 11.19 = 35.99 \]
Thus, the original price of each leotard is \(\boxed{35.99}\).