Hank is incorrect because not all square roots are rational. Specifically, the square root of a number is rational only if that number is a perfect square. In this case, since \( \sqrt{25} = 5 \), which is a rational number, Hank's reasoning overlooks that the claim was more about the general nature of square roots rather than specifically about \( \sqrt{25} \). His statement implies that all square roots are rational, which is not true (for example, \( \sqrt{2} \) is irrational). Therefore, the correct response is:
Hank is incorrect because not all square roots are rational.