Explain why Bayer's test give results for unsaturation test only and do not give for Carboxylic acid group and aldehyde

1 answer

Bayer's test, also known as the Bayer test for unsaturation, is a chemical test used to identify the presence of carbon-carbon double bonds (alkenes) or carbon-carbon triple bonds (alkynes) in organic compounds. The reaction involves the addition of potassium permanganate (KMnO4) to the unsaturated compound, which leads to the formation of a diol through the oxidation of the alkene or alkyne. This reaction typically produces a color change, as the purple color of KMnO4 disappears upon reaction.

Here are the reasons why Bayer's test specifically indicates unsaturation but does not give positive results for carboxylic acids and aldehydes:

  1. Mechanism of Reaction:

    • Bayer’s test is specifically designed to detect unsaturation (double or triple bonds) via the oxidative cleavage reaction. Carboxylic acids and aldehydes do not possess carbon-carbon double or triple bonds, so they will not react with KMnO4 in the same manner that alkenes and alkynes do.
  2. Nature of Functional Groups:

    • Carbonyl groups (C=O) present in aldehydes and carboxylic acids are not detected by Bayer’s test, as the focus is on the presence of carbon-carbon pi bonds (C=C or C≡C). While KMnO4 can oxidize aldehydes and carboxylic acids, it does not lead to the same observable color change or reaction characteristic of the presence of unsaturation.
  3. Reaction Products:

    • When aldehydes or carboxylic acids react with KMnO4, they undergo further oxidation to form carboxylic acids or carbon dioxide, respectively, rather than the formation of a diol that signifies unsaturation. This change is not associated with the same identifiable color change as would be observed in the presence of unsaturation.

In summary, Bayer's test is specific for identifying alkenes and alkynes due to its mechanism of reaction that targets carbon-carbon multiple bonds. It does not provide information about the presence of carboxylic acids or aldehydes because these compounds lack the unsaturation that the test is designed to detect.