Essay Question: Look at the Protagonist's motivators and then look at the antagonists motivators. Are their motives similar at all? Do these characters react differently to intrinsic or extrinsic motivators?

Question

The story is cranes by Hwang Sun- Won. My story doesn’t have the commander in it, so I need another antagonist. Can you please help?
I need a Topic Sentence for the essay question above with the Claim/Reason #1 :

(Topic sentences should address a SPECIFIC ASPECT OF YOUR THESIS. Does your topic sentence read like PLOT SUMMARY? If so, change it.)

I need a sentence that Explains the idea further, but in your own words - paraphrase in one to three sentences. This will be used later when we put all of the sentences together in one paragraph. So please make it good.

Sentences with Textual Evidence to support the claim above.

Sentences with Analysis/Explanation of how textual evidence supports claim. This should be TWICE as long as your Textual Evidence and Examples.

I also need to Connect the information in this paragraph to the thesis statement in one or two sentences.

Body Paragraph #1 (all put together) Copy and paste all sentences above into one paragraph. This whole paragraph will be put into your essay.

Answer 1

Topic Sentence: The protagonist and the new antagonist in "Cranes" exhibit differing motivators and responses to intrinsic and extrinsic factors.

In the story "Cranes" by Hwang Sun-Won, the protagonist, Song-sam, is motivated by a deep-rooted friendship with his childhood friend, Tok-chae, and a sense of duty to protect him. On the other hand, the new antagonist, Officer Kim, is driven by his allegiance to the government and his duty to uphold the law.

For example, Song-sam's motivation to protect Tok-chae is evident when he risks his own safety to save his friend from execution. This is shown when he pleads with Officer Kim, "Just wait a while, please give him a chance." In contrast, Officer Kim's motivation is to enforce the law and maintain government order, as seen when he declares, "As one of the people's police, I cannot act arbitrarily. He has committed a crime and must pay for it."

The textual evidence illustrates how Song-sam and Officer Kim react differently to intrinsic and extrinsic motivators. While Song-sam's actions are guided by personal connections and loyalty, Officer Kim's actions are guided by external obligations and duty to authority. This fundamental difference in motivators leads to contrasting outcomes for the characters in the story.

This comparison between the protagonist and the new antagonist in "Cranes" highlights the complexity of human motivation and the varied responses individuals have to different sources of motivation. Both characters illustrate how intrinsic and extrinsic factors can shape their actions and decisions throughout the story.