To match the sentences with Erik's effect on the story, here's how they would pair up:
Tamara is completely swayed by Erik's looks and cleverness.
Fascinated by the handsome stranger and certain that he really was a god, she happily said yes and called her family.
Tamara is left grieving by Erik's dishonesty and trickery.
In the East, on the terrace of a magnificent palace, a young girl sadly glanced at the sky from time to time, hoping that the god who had suddenly disappeared would come back again.
Erik is left in dishonor after failing to honor others.
Erik managed to swim ashore and return to Copenhagen, where he sang sad songs at street corners for a living.
Note: The last sentence may not perfectly fit the description of dishonor but can indicate the consequences of his actions. If certain contextual details were provided in the passage, a more precise pairing might be possible.