The correct answer to describe what happens when two tectonic plates move apart is typically represented by the formation of new crust. In the context of tectonic plate interactions, this is often seen at mid-ocean ridges where magma rises to fill the gap created by the separating plates.
Therefore, the most accurate response would be:
a: Diagram A: A new plate from underneath filled in the gap that was created by the plates moving apart.
This reflects the geological process of seafloor spreading, where magma rises to form new oceanic crust as the plates diverge.