Consider this claim:

Question

It is more enjoyable to eat ice cream in a cone than in a cup.
Now consider how someone might argue against this. Which sentence presents the strongest and most reasonable counterclaim to the above claim?
Ice cream cones add unnecessary carbohydrates to an already sugary treat.
When ice cream melts, it can dissolve the bottom of a cone and leak through.
Ice cream cones completely ruin the pure, delicious taste of ice cream.

Answer 1

The sentence that presents the strongest and most reasonable counterclaim to the claim that "it is more enjoyable to eat ice cream in a cone than in a cup" is:

"When ice cream melts, it can dissolve the bottom of a cone and leak through."

This counterclaim addresses a practical downside of eating ice cream in a cone, highlighting a potential issue that could detract from the enjoyment of the experience. It presents a specific scenario that could negatively affect the enjoyment factor, making it a compelling argument against the original claim.