Walt Whitman's "Song of Myself" and Emily Dickinson's poem number 712, often titled "Because I could not stop for Death," present contrasting perspectives on the human experience, individuality, and mortality. Here’s a comparative analysis of the two works:
Themes
-
Individuality and Self:
- Whitman: "Song of Myself" celebrates the self and the individual experience. Whitman embraces a broad, transcendental view of humanity, where the self is interconnected with the universe, nature, and other people. He uses an inclusive tone, inviting readers to recognize their own identities within his.
- Dickinson: In contrast, Dickinson's approach to individuality is more introspective and internalized. Poem 712 reflects on personal existence and mortality in a private, contemplative manner. Dickinson's use of slant rhyme and compact language emphasizes a more personal experience of self.
-
Mortality:
- Whitman: While Whitman acknowledges death, it is not the central focus of "Song of Myself." Instead, he treats death as a natural part of life, celebrating the continuity of existence through natural cycles and the immortality of the soul.
- Dickinson: Dickinson’s "712" personifies death, framing it as a courteous suitor who takes the speaker on a journey. This portrayal makes death an intimate, inevitable part of life, reflecting a more personal and perhaps anxious grappling with mortality.
Style and Structure
-
Form:
- Whitman: The poem employs free verse, which allows for a fluid and expansive exploration of ideas. This structure supports his themes of inclusivity and boundless identity.
- Dickinson: Her poem is structured with short lines and quatrains, often featuring an ABAB rhyme scheme. This formal brevity enhances the poem's focus and allows for deep introspection within a compact format.
-
Imagery and Language:
- Whitman: His vivid and often exuberant imagery portrays a multitude of experiences and sensations, celebrating the richness of life. The language is democratic, reflecting the diversity of voices and experiences.
- Dickinson: She uses concise and sometimes ambiguous imagery, creating an atmosphere that is more contemplative and restrained. Her diction is precise, often juxtaposing life and death in ways that provoke thought and introspection.
Tone and Perspective
-
Tone:
- Whitman: The tone of "Song of Myself" is exuberant and celebratory, filled with a sense of joy and affirmation of life. Whitman's voice is confident, and his expansive view of existence invites readers to share in this joy.
- Dickinson: The tone in Dickinson's "712" is more subdued and reflective, tinged with a sense of resignation. The poet’s exploration of death conveys a mixture of acceptance and unease, prompting contemplation rather than exuberance.
-
Perspective:
- Whitman: Whitman speaks from a collective perspective, using the first person to create a connection with humanity at large. His vision encompasses various identities and experiences, melding them into a singular experience.
- Dickinson: Dickinson's perspective is profoundly personal and individual, drawing on inner emotion and introspection. The reader feels a direct connection to the speaker's internal struggle with life and death.
Conclusion
Both "Song of Myself" and Dickinson's "712" deeply explore the complexities of individual existence and the human condition, but they do so through distinct lenses. Whitman employs a broad, celebratory perspective that merges individuality with universality, while Dickinson offers a focused, introspective examination of mortality and personal experience. Together, they enrich the American poetic landscape, offering diverse reflections on self, life, and death.