Columbus may have discovered a "new world" for Europeans,but the people who already lived in America didn't feel that way.should be still say that Columbus "discovered" America?

Answer 1

The term "discovered" can be problematic when discussing Columbus's arrival in the Americas because it overlooks the presence and civilizations of Indigenous peoples who had inhabited the continent for thousands of years prior to his arrival in 1492. From this perspective, Columbus did not discover a "new world," but rather encountered a land that was already home to diverse cultures, languages, and societies.

Using the term "discovered" can perpetuate the narrative that ignores or diminishes the histories and experiences of Indigenous peoples. Many contemporary scholars and activists advocate for more accurate language that recognizes the complexity of history and respects the rights and perspectives of Indigenous communities.

Instead of saying Columbus "discovered" America, it may be more appropriate to refer to his voyages as the beginnings of European exploration and colonization in the Americas, which had profound and often devastating effects on Indigenous populations. Engaging in this more nuanced conversation allows for a broader understanding of history that respects all voices involved.