Claim: Queenie pushed Arthur down stairs

Question

Evidence: Arthur is laying on the floor at the bottom of the stairs on his back with both legs on steps.

give a reasoning that would connect the evidence to the claim above. 2 sentences In 5th graders response

Answer 1

The evidence shows that Arthur is on the floor at the bottom of the stairs in a way that suggests he fell down. Since Queenie was the last person seen near the stairs, it makes it likely that she pushed him down.