Choose one selection from the list below and critique its theme. First, identify its possible themes, and then judge how well you feel the author developed the theme(s). Do you agree with the theme(s)? How does the author communicate the theme(s)? Cite specific events and character descriptions that support your statements.

Question

"The Gift of the Magi"
"Fabric of Their Lives"
"To Be of Use"
"I Hear America Singing"
"The Necklace"

Answer 1

"The Gift of the Magi" by O. Henry

Possible themes: Sacrifice, love, selflessness, materialism

In "The Gift of the Magi," the theme of sacrifice is prevalent as a newlywed couple, Della and Jim, both make significant sacrifices in order to provide a meaningful Christmas gift for each other. Della sells her prized possession, her long hair, to buy a chain for Jim's pocket watch, while Jim sells his pocket watch to buy combs for Della's hair. This act of selflessness and sacrifice shows their deep love for each other.

The author, O. Henry, effectively develops this theme by portraying the couple's genuine intentions and the lengths they are willing to go to make each other happy. The descriptions of Della and Jim's actions and emotions throughout the story emphasize their selflessness and love. Additionally, the twist ending, where it is revealed that their sacrifices render the gifts useless, further highlights the theme of sacrifice and the true value of love over material possessions.

I agree with the theme of sacrifice and love in the story as it is heartwarming to see the couple's willingness to give up something important to them in order to express their love for each other. O. Henry effectively communicates this theme through the dialogue, actions, and emotions of the characters, making it a memorable and touching story.