Charges of +3 µC and –5 µC are 2 mm from each other. The –5 µC charge is replaced with a +5 µC charge.

How will the electrical force between the charges compare with the original force?

same force, but in the opposite direction
same force, but in the same direction
greater force, but in the opposite direction
greater force, but in the same direction

1 answer

To analyze the situation, we can use Coulomb's law, which states that the electrical force between two point charges is given by:

\[ F = k \frac{|q_1 q_2|}{r^2} \]

where \( F \) is the magnitude of the force between the charges, \( k \) is Coulomb's constant, \( q_1 \) and \( q_2 \) are the magnitudes of the charges, and \( r \) is the distance between them.

  1. Original Situation:

    • Charges: \( q_1 = +3 , \mu\text{C} \) and \( q_2 = -5 , \mu\text{C} \)
    • Distance: \( r = 2 , \text{mm} = 0.002 , \text{m} \)
    • Force (magnitude): \[ F_{original} = k \frac{|(+3 , \mu\text{C})(-5 , \mu\text{C})|}{(0.002)^2} \]

    The force will be attractive because one charge is positive and the other is negative.

  2. New Situation:

    • Charges: \( q_1 = +3 , \mu\text{C} \) and \( q_2 = +5 , \mu\text{C} \)
    • Distance: \( r = 2 , \text{mm} = 0.002 , \text{m} \)
    • Force (magnitude): \[ F_{new} = k \frac{|(+3 , \mu\text{C})(+5 , \mu\text{C})|}{(0.002)^2} \]

    The force will be repulsive because both charges are positive.

Now, we can compare the magnitudes of the forces:

  • Original force: \[ F_{original} = k \frac{15 , \mu\text{C}^2}{(0.002)^2} \]

  • New force: \[ F_{new} = k \frac{15 , \mu\text{C}^2}{(0.002)^2} \]

Both forces have the same magnitude, specifically \( k \frac{15 , \mu\text{C}^2}{(0.002)^2} \), but they are in opposite directions (attractive for original, repulsive for new).

Conclusion: The correct answer is: same force, but in the opposite direction.