Casey is in great shape. She does aerobic and anaerobic workouts on a consistent basis. Sarah is not in good shape. She has never worked out in her life. Casey and Sarah go on a one-mile walk together. What is MOST likely to happen in this scenario?

Question

(1 point)
Responses

Casey’s lungs will need to work harder than Sarah’s.
Sarah’s heart will need to work less than Casey’s
Casey will be less winded than Sarah.
Sarah will be more flexible than Casey.

Answer 1

The most likely outcome in this scenario is: Casey will be less winded than Sarah.

Since Casey is in great shape and regularly engages in aerobic and anaerobic workouts, she will have better cardiovascular fitness and endurance compared to Sarah, who has never worked out and is not in good shape. As a result, Casey is likely to handle the walk with less breathlessness or fatigue than Sarah.

Answer 2

Casey’s lungs will need to work harder than Sarah’s.
Don't you think this is a better answer?

Answer 3

While it might seem that Casey's lungs could have to work harder during the walk because she may be accustomed to higher intensity workouts, the reality is that an individual in better shape (like Casey) typically experiences a more efficient cardiovascular and respiratory response even during moderate activities, such as walking.

In this scenario, since Sarah is not in good shape and has never worked out, her body would likely struggle more with the physical exertion of the walk. Therefore, it is expected that Casey will be less winded than Sarah accurately reflects their respective physical conditions and responses to the activity.

So, the original assessment remains that Casey will be less winded than Sarah is the most appropriate answer in this context.