Carlos made the first error when he incorrectly added \(-18\) and \(52\).
Here's the breakdown of the steps:
- He correctly started with the equation \(14x - 52 = -18\).
- When he added \(52\) to both sides, he should have computed \(-18 + 52\) correctly. The correct calculation is \(-18 + 52 = 34\), but Carlos arrived at \(218\), which is incorrect.
Thus, he made his first error in the addition step when trying to simplify \( -18 + 52\).