Calculate and compare the volume of the two figures in the image. Choose which statement is true.

(1 point)
Responses

The two figures are similar because the volumes have a ratio of 5 : 1
.
The two figures are similar because the volumes have a ratio of ratio of 5 to 1 .

The two figures are similar because the volumes have a ratio of 125 : 1
.
The two figures are similar because the volumes have a ratio of ratio of 125 to 1 .

The two figures are not similar because there is no scale factor stated for the volume.
The two figures are not similar because there is no scale factor stated for the volume.

The two figures are not similar because the volumes are not the same.

1 answer

To determine the correct statement regarding the two figures, we first need to understand the relationship between the volume of similar figures and their linear dimensions (scale factor).

If two figures are similar, then their volumes will be related by the cube of the scale factor of their corresponding linear dimensions. For example, if the scale factor is \( k \), then the ratio of their volumes will be \( k^3 \).

Now, looking at the options given:

  1. "The two figures are similar because the volumes have a ratio of 5 : 1."
  2. "The two figures are similar because the volumes have a ratio of ratio of 5 to 1."
  3. "The two figures are similar because the volumes have a ratio of 125 : 1."
  4. "The two figures are similar because the volumes have a ratio of ratio of 125 to 1."
  5. "The two figures are not similar because there is no scale factor stated for the volume."
  6. "The two figures are not similar because the volumes are not the same."

Analysis:

  • If the ratio of volumes is \( 5:1 \), then the scale factor \( k \) must be \( \sqrt[3]{5} \) (approximately \( 1.71 \)).
  • If the ratio of volumes is \( 125:1 \), then the scale factor \( k \) would be \( \sqrt[3]{125} = 5 \).

Since we need to check whether the figures are similar based on the given volume ratios:

  • If the volume ratio is \( 5:1 \) or \( 125:1 \), the figures can still be similar based on the respective scale factors.
  • If no information about their linear measurements is provided, then we cannot definitively conclude their similarity.
  • The last option also implies non-similarity based on volumes not being equal, but that doesn't dismiss similarity entirely.

Conclusion:

Without knowing the actual volumes or the scale factor, we cannot definitively say whether the figures are similar or not based on the information given. Hence, the most appropriate choice could be:

"The two figures are not similar because there is no scale factor stated for the volume."

This suggests that without specific information regarding the scale, we cannot determine similarity based upon volume ratios alone.