"But I didn't eat your cookies, you ate them last night" which is the Independant and the dependent clauses

3 answers

In the sentence "But I didn't eat your cookies, you ate them last night," there are two independent clauses:

  1. "I didn't eat your cookies"
  2. "you ate them last night"

Both clauses can stand alone as complete sentences, which is a characteristic of independent clauses. The "But" at the beginning indicates a contrast or contradiction between the two statements.

There are no dependent clauses in this particular sentence.

I didn't eat your cookies, but you did" have about this one

In the sentence "I didn't eat your cookies, but you did," there are again two independent clauses:

  1. "I didn't eat your cookies"
  2. "you did"

Both clauses can stand alone as complete sentences, which means they are independent clauses. The conjunction "but" connects the two clauses to show a contrast between the speaker's statement and the implied action of the other person. There are no dependent clauses in this sentence either.