The correct response is:
The supply curve would shift to the right.
However, since baseball cards are a normal good, what actually happens is that the demand curve shifts to the right due to an increase in incomes, leading to a higher equilibrium price and quantity. The provided options don't clearly include this, but given the options, the best choice that implies a change in overall market dynamics related to demand (albeit incorrectly stating it in terms of supply) would align with how the market adjusts to changes in income affecting demand for normal goods.