Baby Thesis #1/Claim: One way that Booker T. Washington was similar to W.E.B. Du Bois is that both leaders sought to uplift African Americans and improve their social and economic conditions in post-Reconstruction America.
Evidence:
-
Advocacy for Education: Both Washington and Du Bois emphasized the importance of education as a means to empower African Americans. Washington promoted vocational training through institutions like the Tuskegee Institute, believing that practical skills would help African Americans achieve economic self-sufficiency. In contrast, Du Bois advocated for a liberal arts education, arguing that a “Talented Tenth” of the African American population should be educated to lead the community toward equality and civil rights.
-
Community Development: Washington and Du Bois both believed in the necessity of community effort to improve the lives of African Americans. Washington focused on economic development and entrepreneurship within the Black community, encouraging people to establish businesses and gain financial independence. Du Bois, although he emphasized political action and civil rights, also acknowledged the significance of community efforts in raising the status and visibility of African Americans.
-
Response to Racism: Both leaders responded to the pervasive racism and discrimination faced by African Americans in their time. Washington promoted a strategy of accommodation to gradually gain respect from white society, advocating for patience and hard work as ways to overcome prejudice. Du Bois, however, responded with a more confrontational approach, calling out systemic racism and demanding immediate rights and justice.
Reasoning/Analysis:
Despite their similarities, W.E.B. Du Bois’s approach was more effective in the long run because he campaigned for immediate civil rights and higher education for African Americans. While Washington’s focus on vocational training and economic self-help addressed the pressing needs of the Black community during his time, it often resulted in a compromise that delayed demands for civil rights. Du Bois’s insistence on political engagement and higher education laid the groundwork for the Civil Rights Movement and inspired future generations to actively fight against discrimination and inequality. By advocating for immediate access to full citizenship rights, higher education, and an end to segregation, Du Bois provided a more comprehensive framework for long-term social change, enabling African Americans to challenge systemic injustices directly and assert their rightful place in society.