Assess the strength of the following argument: Cyclones can cause famine. Civil war can cause famine. Therefore, cyclones are a type of civil war.

Question

Question 6 options:

The is a strong argument.

This argument is neither strong nor weak.

The is a weak argument.

The strength of this argument cannot be assessed.

Answer 1

The argument presented is weak. It incorrectly assumes a causal relationship and draws a conclusion that cyclones are a type of civil war solely based on both having the potential to cause famine. This logical leap does not follow, as cyclones and civil wars are fundamentally different phenomena. Therefore, the correct option is:

This is a weak argument.