In this excerpt from Thomas Paine's "Common Sense," he expresses a clear skepticism regarding the possibility of reaching a satisfactory compromise with Britain. Paine argues that Britain has shown no interest in negotiating terms that would be acceptable to the American colonies. He emphasizes that any potential terms offered by Britain would likely not be worth the sacrifices—both in terms of lives lost and resources expended—that the colonies have already made in their struggle.
Paine advocates for a decisive break from British rule rather than attempting to negotiate with a government that he believes has demonstrated an unwillingness to treat the colonies fairly. He suggests that the cost of continued compromise would not only be unacceptable but would also undermine the sacrifices already made. His position is a call for independence, reflecting a belief that the colonies should no longer rely on Britain in any capacity.
As for whether one agrees with Paine's argument, it largely depends on one's perspective on the situation at that historical moment. Supporters of independence might find Paine's reasoning compelling, as it articulates a desire for self-determination and a rejection of enduring exploitation. Conversely, others might argue for the potential merits of reconciliation and compromise, believing that preserving ties with Britain could ultimately serve the colonies' long-term interests. Overall, Paine’s rhetoric captures the urgency and desperation felt by many colonists, making a powerful case for the revolutionary path they ultimately chose.