Analyze colonizer challenges to tribal sovereignty in the early United States.(1 point)

Question

Responses

Colonizers challenged tribal sovereignty by trading with Indigenous groups and sharing farming techniques with them.
Colonizers challenged tribal sovereignty by trading with Indigenous groups and sharing farming techniques with them.

Colonizers challenged tribal sovereignty by stealing land and introducing diseases, plants, and animals that devastated Indigenous land and peoples.
Colonizers challenged tribal sovereignty by stealing land and introducing diseases, plants, and animals that devastated Indigenous land and peoples.

Colonizers challenged tribal sovereignty by allowing Indigenous peoples to negotiate with the American government fairly and allowing them to keep living on their land.
Colonizers challenged tribal sovereignty by allowing Indigenous peoples to negotiate with the American government fairly and allowing them to keep living on their land.

American colonizers did not challenge tribal sovereignty. They worked together with Indigenous people and respected their rights.
American colonizers did not challenge tribal sovereignty. They worked together with Indigenous people and respected their rights.
Skip to navigation
page 21 of 21

Answer 1

In analyzing the challenges to tribal sovereignty in the early United States, it's crucial to consider the historical context and the actions of colonizers during this period. Below is an evaluation of the provided responses.

1. Response on trading and sharing farming techniques:

   • This response oversimplifies the relationship between colonizers and Indigenous groups. While there were instances of trade and the exchange of agricultural practices, this does not capture the overarching impact of colonization. These interactions often came with coercive elements and did not equate to respect for tribal sovereignty.

2. Response on stealing land and introducing devastation:

   • This response accurately reflects the significant challenges to tribal sovereignty. Colonizers not only appropriated indigenous lands through treaties often made under duress but also introduced diseases and invasive species that severely impacted Indigenous populations and their traditional ways of life. This encapsulates the erosion of tribal sovereignty and the violent nature of colonization.

3. Response on negotiating fairly:

   • This response presents an inaccurate portrayal of the relationship between Indigenous peoples and the American government. While there were treaties made, many were often not upheld, and negotiations were frequently conducted under pressure. Therefore, it is misleading to suggest that Indigenous peoples were allowed to negotiate fairly regarding their land and rights.

4. Response claiming no challenge to sovereignty:

   • This response is historically inaccurate. The colonizers' expansionist policies and military actions drastically undermined Indigenous rights and sovereignty. The collaborative narratives often overlook the systemic oppression and violence faced by Indigenous populations.

In summary, the most accurate representation of the challenges to tribal sovereignty is found in the second response, which highlights the detrimental actions of colonizers, including land theft and the introduction of diseases. This reflects the historical realities faced by Indigenous groups in the early United States.