Alice and Andrew are discussing thesis development. Alice argues that a topic becomes a thesis if we want to write about the topic. Andrew, on the other hand, maintains that a topic is not a thesis but that a thesis is the foundation of a topic. Who is correct?

Question

A. Alice is correct.
B. Andrew is correct.
C. Neither Alice nor Andrew is correct.
D. Both are partially correct.

My answer is C

Answer 1

I agree.