A town is considering adopting a flood mitigation strategy. The results of its study are shown in the table below. Which of the following statements provides the best analysis of the data?

Question

(1 point)
Responses

The town should build the diversion channels because this option is more cost efficient within the first 5 years.
The town should build the diversion channels because this option is more cost efficient within the first 5 years.

The town should elevate buildings in the flood plain because the maintenance costs are lower.
The town should elevate buildings in the flood plain because the maintenance costs are lower.

The town should elevate buildings in the flood plain because the work will be completed sooner.
The town should elevate buildings in the flood plain because the work will be completed sooner.

The town should build the diversion channels because this option will displace the most people.
The town should build the diversion channels because this option will displace the most people.
Skip to navigation

Answer 1

It seems you've provided potential responses to a question regarding flood mitigation strategies, but without the specific data or table that outlines the costs, benefits, timelines, and other relevant factors associated with each option.

However, I can offer some guidance on how to evaluate each of the provided responses critically based on common analysis principles:

1. Cost Efficiency in the First 5 Years: A statement focusing on cost efficiency is strong if the data shows that diversion channels provide a better return on investment in those early years compared to other options.

2. Maintenance Costs: If the analysis indicates that elevating buildings has significantly lower long-term maintenance costs compared to diversion channels or other strategies, then this would support that choice.

3. Timeline for Completion: This is a valid consideration, especially if the urgency of flood mitigation is high. If elevating buildings can be completed more quickly and still provides adequate protection, that is an important factor.

4. Displacement of People: While displacement is an important factor, it’s generally not ideal to choose an option simply because it displaces more people. Therefore, this statement may not be the best rationale for decision-making.

Without the specific data from the study, it is difficult to determine which statement offers the best analysis. You would want to select the option whose rationale is strongly supported by the findings in the table. Please provide the relevant data for a more tailored analysis!