A student is investigating the distribution of charges in insulators. The student will place an aluminum metal can on top of a foam cup and touch the side of the foam cup with a negatively charged rod. The set up for the investigation is shown in the diagram.

What will most likely happen to the electrons when the rod touches the foam cup?

A.
The electrons will pass to the foam cup but will remain in a localized, positively charged area on the cup where the rod was placed.

B.
The electrons will pass to the foam cup but will remain in a localized, negatively charged area on the cup where the rod was placed.

C.
The electrons will pass from the foam cup to the aluminum can, and both the foam cup and the aluminum can will become positively charged.

D.
The electrons will pass from the foam cup to the aluminum can, and both the foam cup and the aluminum can will become negatively charged.

3 answers

When the negatively charged rod touches the foam cup, it will likely transfer some of its excess electrons to the foam cup. This process is due to the close contact between the negatively charged rod and the neutral foam cup, allowing electrons to move.

Considering the options provided:

A. The electrons will pass to the foam cup but will remain in a localized, positively charged area on the cup where the rod was placed.
This is incorrect because the foam cup would become negatively charged overall, not create a localized positive area where the rod was.

B. The electrons will pass to the foam cup but will remain in a localized, negatively charged area on the cup where the rod was placed.
This is somewhat misleading since the entire foam cup will be negatively charged after the contact, not just a localized area.

C. The electrons will pass from the foam cup to the aluminum can, and both the foam cup and the aluminum can will become positively charged.
This is incorrect because it suggests that electrons leave the foam cup when, in fact, they would be coming from the rod to the cup.

D. The electrons will pass from the foam cup to the aluminum can, and both the foam cup and the aluminum can will become negatively charged.
This is incorrect because the foam cup would become negatively charged, but the aluminum can is neutral and will remain neutral unless another charged object is involved.

Given these explanations, the most accurate possibility—despite the inadequacies of all choices—would be:

B. The electrons will pass to the foam cup but will remain in a localized, negatively charged area on the cup where the rod was placed.

The foam cup will indeed become negatively charged overall after contact, but initially, there can be a localized effect near the area of contact. Therefore, option B is the least incorrect in this context.

then whats the answer

Based on the context of your original question, the best answer among the provided options is:

B. The electrons will pass to the foam cup but will remain in a localized, negatively charged area on the cup where the rod was placed.

This option correctly conveys that the negatively charged electrons from the rod will move to the foam cup, resulting in an overall negative charge on the cup. While the specific wording about remaining "localized" may not perfectly describe the overall situation, it is the most suitable choice given the options available.