The argument that best supports the student's claim is:
Heavier objects need greater force than lighter objects to accelerate at the same rate.
This argument aligns with Newton's second law of motion (F = ma), which states that the force applied on an object is equal to the mass of the object multiplied by its acceleration. Since box 1 accelerates more (10 m/s²) than box 2 (5 m/s²) with the same force (40 N), it follows that box 1 must have a smaller mass. If both boxes were to experience the same force but different accelerations, the box that accelerates more must indeed have a smaller mass.