The correct response to the student's claim is:
She is wrong. The higher the drop, the more kinetic energy the ball will have upon hitting the ground.
The kinetic energy of an object just before it hits the ground is equal to the gravitational potential energy it had at the height from which it was dropped. This means that the higher the drop, the more gravitational potential energy is converted into kinetic energy, resulting in a higher kinetic energy just before impact. Therefore, a ball dropped from a height of 3.0 meters would indeed have more than 96 joules of kinetic energy, assuming there are no other forces (like air resistance) significantly affecting its fall.