Question

“Jim! There’s something wrong with the air! That’s why Claribel’s passed out. I’ve just remembered that miners used to carry canaries down to warn them of gas.”


“Nonsense!” said Jim. “The alarms would have gone off. We’ve got duplicate circuits, operating independently.”


“Er — the second alarm circuit isn’t connected up yet,” his assistant reminded him. That shook Jim; he left without a word, while we stood arguing and passing the oxygen bottle around like a pipe of peace.


He came back ten minutes later with a sheepish expression. It was one of those accidents that couldn’t possibly happen; we’d had one of our rare eclipses by Earth’s shadow that night; part of the air purifier had frozen up, and the single alarm in the circuit had failed to go off. Half a million dollars’ worth of chemical and electronic engineering had let us down completely. Without Claribel, we should soon have been slightly dead.


So now, if you visit any space station, don’t be surprised if you hear an inexplicable snatch of birdsong. There’s no need to be alarmed: on the contrary, in fact. It will mean that you’re being doubly safeguarded, at practically no extra expense.


"Feathered Friend" by Sir Arthur C. Clarke, from The Other Side of the Sky. Copyright ©1957. Used with permission. All rights reserved.

1

2
Assessment: How does the setting affect the conflict, or problem, in the story? Use details from the text to support your answer.

Answer 1

The story’s setting—a space station—directly creates and shapes the central problem. Because the characters are in space they are completely dependent on engineered life‑support systems: when the air purifier “froze up” during an “eclipse by Earth’s shadow,” breathable air became a life‑or‑death issue. That dependence raises the stakes: Claribel “passed out” and, as the narrator says, “without Claribel, we should soon have been slightly dead.”

The confined, technological environment also explains why a single equipment failure becomes critical. Jim trusted “duplicate circuits, operating independently,” but the assistant reveals the second circuit “isn’t connected up yet,” so the lone alarm failed to warn them. In other words, isolation in space magnifies the consequences of design or installation errors that might be less catastrophic on Earth.

Finally, the setting produces the ironic resolution: because high‑tech systems can fail in unique ways in space, the characters revive a low‑tech safeguard from mining history—the canary. The narrator notes that you may hear “an inexplicable snatch of birdsong” on stations as a cheap, practical backup. In sum, the space setting creates a distinctive hazard (freezing air purifier during eclipse), makes redundancy and small failures crucial, and even dictates the surprising, pragmatic solution.