Question

Now you should be prepared to write a draft of your essay. Make sure you have done the following. Check all of the boxes that apply.

I have written a clear claim as my thesis.

I have provided reasons and evidence to support my claim.

I have identified a counterargument and I know how I will respond to it.

I have written a strong outline.

Answer 1

Here’s a quick checklist plus short criteria so you can accurately “check” each box. Read each item, then mark it done if your work meets the criteria. If you want, paste your thesis/outline/evidence and I’ll check them for you.

- [ ] I have written a clear claim as my thesis.
- Criteria: One sentence near the start that states your main position/argument clearly and specifically (not a topic or question). It should be arguable (someone could disagree) and set the focus for the whole essay.
- Quick fix if needed: Turn a topic into a claim by picking a position and adding a reason: “X should/should not happen because Y.”

- [ ] I have provided reasons and evidence to support my claim.
- Criteria: At least 2–3 distinct reasons that directly back the thesis, each paired with evidence (facts, data, quotes, examples, or logical explanation). Evidence should be cited or identified (source or type).
- Quick fix if needed: For each reason ask “How do I know this?” and add one concrete example or source.

- [ ] I have identified a counterargument and I know how I will respond to it.
- Criteria: You state a plausible opposing view (one or two sentences) and either refute it (show why it’s weak/incorrect) or concede part of it and explain why your thesis still stands (rebuttal or qualification).
- Quick fix if needed: Use a phrase like “Some argue that X; however, Y undermines that claim because Z.”

- [ ] I have written a strong outline.
- Criteria: Outline shows essay structure: intro with thesis, body paragraphs (each with main point, evidence, and link back to thesis), counterargument paragraph + rebuttal, and conclusion that restates thesis and shows significance. Order of points is logical and builds the case.
- Quick fix if needed: Arrange your reasons from strongest to weakest or from most general to most specific; list the evidence you’ll use in each paragraph.

If you want, paste:
- your thesis sentence and I’ll say whether it’s clear and arguable;
- one body paragraph topic with the supporting evidence and I’ll evaluate it;
- your counterargument + planned response and I’ll suggest improvements;
- or your full outline and I’ll give targeted feedback and a suggested revision.

Which boxes can I check for you now?