Question

Closer
A. Gautam

My sister Natalie wanted to grow up in seconds and not in years. I was left behind to catch up in real time. Only two years apart, I also felt decades away from her. Natalie wanted privacy, personal room, and mother’s pretty possessions at ten. I longed for her cuddles, which she only dispensed when she had upset me and was sorry. I loved my big sister with every ounce of my being though she felt weighed down by my displays of affection.

“When I was your age, your aunt Jen and I weren’t close,” our mother confessed. “Now, we can’t get enough of each other. Your grandparents are really old, and we share our worries and responsibilities, you know.”

I wasn’t ready to think about that—my beautiful mother being frail or my towering father using a cane. I suspected Natalie would be ahead in the care arrangements and that I would try to play catch-up. I wondered if I would always be just a shadow in Natalie’s life until the day I caught her sobbing in the hallway.

“You didn’t see anything,” Natalie said between sobs and rushed to her room, which she didn’t seal with a locked door.

Entering her neat room, which was a furniture catalog, was a privilege. The veneer of the green curtains added a layer of beauty to the windows. Except for crumbled tissues in the trashcan, nothing seemed unkempt. What had been bothering my perfect sister?

“What’s wrong?” I asked and sat on the edge of the bed to take up the smallest possible space. Then, I spotted a broken friendship bracelet by the night lamp. How could I have not noticed before? Carly hadn’t come over in months. Natalie wasn’t on the phone every free minute of Saturday and Sunday. I had been buried in books and band practice and failed to see my big sister’s loneliness. “Do you want to watch Zombie Cheer together? We don’t have to talk. We can just be…together.”

Natalie lunged at me to hold me tight and wailed until my hair was damp. I let her. Then, she dried her face with tissues and took me by the hand to the living room. Mother had already set up two big bowls of popcorn, which looked like heaps of comfort. Mother always knew everything.
Based on these sentences from the story, what can the reader conclude about Nataile?

Then, I spotted a broken friendship bracelet by the night lamp. How could I have not noticed before? Carly hadn’t come over in months. Natalie wasn’t on the phone every free minute of Saturday and Sunday.
A Natalie has ended her friendship with Carly.
B Natalie no longer has any friends in school.
C Natalie doesn’t share her feelings with the narrator.
D Natalie misses the days when she was close with her sister.
Skip to navigation
© Progress Learning 2026, All Rights Reserved.
Terms(opens in new tab)
|
Privacy(opens in new tab)
PHONE [phone]
|
FAX [phone]
Blog(opens in new tab)

Answer 1

A. Natalie has ended her friendship with Carly.

The broken friendship bracelet and the fact that Carly hasn’t come over in months, plus Natalie not being on the phone as she used to, indicate that her friendship with Carly has ended. The other choices are overgeneralizations or not directly supported by those lines.