Question

School days should be longer. High school students should be in classes for at least nine hours a day to learn more basic knowledge. During the day, students should be in the classroom, rather than out on the street or at home. If they spent this time in the classroom, they could learn more of the basics they need.

Which statement best evaluates the reasoning of this paragraph?

The reasoning is illogical because it just restates the claim.
The reasoning is illogical because it is irrelevant to the claim.
The reasoning is logical because the evidence connects back to the claim.
The reasoning is logical because it provides evidence that supports the claim.

Answer 1

The reasoning is illogical because it just restates the claim. The paragraph offers no real evidence or support—only a repetition that more classroom time would let students "learn more" without explaining how or why.